Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's an absolutely horrible, awful, no good system.

We can act all shocked and horrified that somebody has to leave their home and their roots, but that's what we have already with the current system.

It's just that it's people with less wealth that are being forced out, rather than the policy being applied to everyone equally. Doesn't matter if they lived here for 60 years, retired, then had a medical expense that cost them all their savings and their home. It happens to people that lives here their entire lives, retired into social security, then were priced out.

If we are going to entertain some idea of "demand side management" it had better be applied fairly to everyone, because our entire system is built upon freedom of movement. If one state is going to opt out of that system, it needs to be applied fairly to its population rather than unfairly.

And if we are going to maintain a system where people can be arbitrarily forced out of all their social connections, then we should just make that clear from the start. That would really lessen the demand.

I think that people should have a right to stay where they are. But with that right comes a responsibility to either let more people live nearby.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: