Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> I actually don't like cycling infrastructure because it makes bikes less numerous on the road and drivers less aware that there maybe cyclists.

Have you ever been to the Netherlands or other places where utility cycling is actually encourages?

One of his latest videos debunks vehicular cycling, which I very much agree with.

In places were people who are easily frightened by cars cycle, modal share for bikes is huge. In place where they don't cycle, modal share is pitiful.

It makes a ton of sense, and as someone who doesn't actually ride bikes for sports/fitness/fun, it's something I definitely agree with based on personal experience.

> I am aware of all the arguments. I've heard them all before. Nothing you have mentioned is new. Nothing what they will say is new.

I didn't realize I'm arguing with God, over here. As we all know there was no progress since the Romans, including the fact that these days people still pray to Roman Gods, this discussion is over.





> Have you ever been to the Netherlands or other places where utility cycling is actually encourages?

Yes.

> One of his latest videos debunks vehicular cycling, which I very much agree with.

> In places were people who are easily frightened by cars cycle, modal share for bikes is huge. In place where they don't cycle, modal share is pitiful.

> It makes a ton of sense, and as someone who doesn't actually ride bikes for sports/fitness/fun, it's something I definitely agree with based on personal experience.

"It has been debooked™ because YouTuber said so!" /sarcasm

Can you stop regurgitating stuff a YouTuber has told you? I've formed my opinion after 20 years of cycle commuting and cycling in multiple countries, going to protests and meeting people.

BTW I am pretty sure I've seen these videos before after quickly skimming the titles and thumbnails.

> I didn't realize I'm arguing with God, over here.

The point I am trying to make is that I've heard all the arguments before. They don't change that much. That is because the fundamental disagreement hasn't changed.

I don't have this opinion due to arrogance. I have this opinion because I've heard these arguments you are making before. I told you why I am not convinced, I've listed the reasons why and your response has been "but this Youtuber said X".

Saying that someone has a video which has the same argument that I wasn't convinced by before, isn't going to change my mind.

> As we all know there was no progress since the Romans,

The point I was trying to make is that because the Human condition is something that is not going to go away and almost all conflict is almost always over resources, People generally have similar issues, similar conversations about those issues. Taking jabs at me where you take the worst interpretation of my intent isn't conducive to any discussion.


> Can you stop regurgitating stuff a YouTuber has told you? I've formed my opinion after 20 years of cycle commuting and cycling in multiple countries, going to protests and meeting people.

I've been to several bike friendly countries. They mostly don't practice vehicular cycling and cycling is well established as part of the local culture. Many people drive, bike or use public transportation, depending on their needs. And that's real freedom.

There is no physical reason why most countries in the world - and especially urban areas - couldn't be bike friendly, especially since ebikes exist. Also the vast majority of people are perfectly able to ride a bike (or trike, or hand trike, etc - bikes are a lot more inclusive than usually depicted).

https://youtu.be/FKMDMekErQ0?si=UZhp7zfozao1A61l&t=1043

Cyclists don't hate drivers directly, they just want better bike infrastructure. Which drivers fight tooth and nail. And guess what happens in that case?

You do you, go have fun driving. Just let others enjoy the freedom to ride their bikes safely for commuting/taking kids to school/getting groceries. And when I say "let others enjoy" - don't vote against building bike lanes, protected intersections, multi use paths, secure bike parking, etc.

> The point I was trying to make is that because the Human condition is something that is not going to go away and almost all conflict is almost always over resources, People generally have similar issues, similar conversations about those issues.

History is a spiral, not a circle. It doesn't repeat, but it does rhyme.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: