Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I just want to eventually be able to view NTSC video like it used to be viewed, but without preserving a CRT to do so with.

It was originally proofed on a CRT. It may have been a ridiculously-good and Sony BVM in excellent calibration, but it was still a CRT that had CRT issues.

(I don't care much if nobody else wants that experience. I'll build it myself when I feel that modern displays have become flexible-enough to accomplish my goals.)



A high quality CRT wouldn't have a lot of those issues. And a lot of content wasn't proofed on anything, it's raw camera output. Either way if something came from a camera there's no intent to have half of CRT's problems, and they very likely didn't do any compensation for those problems that would look bad on a better screen.

Wanting the whole package of CRT flaws isn't just playing a record, it's playing a record with a cheap needle. Go ahead if it feels more nostalgic or right to you, and I wish you luck in finding what you want. But I don't think it adds anything, and to some extent it detracts from the original.


I hope that you have a very nice day, and wish that you may reconsider the value of telling others the way in which they shall (and shall not) enjoy their media.


I didn't tell you that. I said "Go ahead if it feels more nostalgic or right to you, and I wish you luck in finding what you want."

So I hope you have a nice day too but also I hope that you don't keep a wrong idea of my comment in your head.

I wasn't being fake and patronizing, there are reasons to want that, it's just that those reasons aren't usually original authorial intent.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: