> All financial systems before Bitcoin were government controlled
Company scrip, community currency, hawala have all existed for centuries.
Also Bitcoin is also government controlled. It lacks the anonymity required to protect participants making it trivial for nation states to influence. And it does nothing to prevent the centralisation of capital that causes so much manipulation in traditional currency systems.
> And over the longer term they all tend to mess it up eventually.
Over the long term the probability of failure of all systems is 1.
> Company scrip, community currency, hawala have all existed for centuries.
All of these have the problem of centralized and permissioned issuance, where one entity can arbitrarily inflate the supply without the knowledge or consent of others.
> Also Bitcoin is also government controlled
In what way?
> It lacks the anonymity required to protect participants
This is false and does not make it government controlled. I’ll concede that there are many ways for one to lose privacy when using Bitcoin though.
> And it does nothing to prevent the centralisation of capital
The ‘centralization of capital’ isn’t an issue Bitcoin aims to solve. One of the big problems Bitcoin solves is the unjust accumulation of capital via arbitrary issuance (IORB, RRP, loans via newly created bank deposits, etc.)
I wonder what it says about me that the only counterexample that came to me is the use of Nuka Cola bottle caps in the Fallout games. But that only works in a post-apocalyotic setting, when there's no longer any manufacturing capability.
Company scrip, community currency, hawala have all existed for centuries.
Also Bitcoin is also government controlled. It lacks the anonymity required to protect participants making it trivial for nation states to influence. And it does nothing to prevent the centralisation of capital that causes so much manipulation in traditional currency systems.
> And over the longer term they all tend to mess it up eventually.
Over the long term the probability of failure of all systems is 1.