Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

You conveniently ignored the illegal part.


Most illegal immigrants entered the country legally and are overstaying on expired visas.

Given the federal government is actively revoking and eliminating massive amounts of visas, they are essentially creating "illegal" immigrants with the stroke of a pen.

If people actually cared about stopping people entering the country illegally, it would be as easy as extending all resident visas and these communities would be happy to turn on the bad actors they moved here to run from.


> Most illegal immigrants entered the country legally and are overstaying on expired visas.

Overstaying an expired visa is illegal bro. What world are we living in?

https://www.uscis.gov/laws-and-policy/other-resources/unlawf...


No one is arguing that it's legal. But it's unfair and misleading to characterize all illegals as willful lawbreakers when what actually happens is usually just a legal rug pull.

The government can change the terms of the visas on a whim. If you've lived in the US with your family for decades and they decide to deny a renewal with no recourse, what realistically are you going to do?

The reality is that most people are illegal simply because both politicians benefited from slapping the label on people for so long. You get the benefit of immigration, but you can pretend to be tough on it, and also deprive large swaths of your working class from expensive benefits and rights.

The existing laws are unfair, unjust, and immoral. Lumping in a huge portion of the working class together with actual drug runners and criminals is an intentional and preventable error.


So you'd send Elon back I assume?


Because I care very little about "legality" of what people do to a virtual entity that we all call "the united states", with all its made up rules.

I learned it from the US itself, and how it treats the rest of the world. Legality is optional and subject to political considerations, and desire for money and power.


[flagged]


then perhaps it would be wise to learn from the fate that befell the native population? ;)




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: