Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Do you really think your friends are qualified to have the opinion

Yes... most of the friends in question (MechEs, as I mentioned) work in power generation, petroleum engineering, etc. Not sure what your friend group looks like.

> We are talking about the long-term health/environmental effects of millions of vehicles after all,

If you're going to act like you're doing some kind of utilitarian calculation, you're going to need to do a more convincing job of recognizing this as a tradeoff space rather than seethingly appealing to "science teams"



And you genuinely don't see how they can be incompetent to have an opinion on the long-term medical/environmental effects of deleting EGR for example? You also don't see how on top of that they might be biased?


Do the "science teams" you're imagining happen to be world-class experts in power generation and particulate medicine and ecology?

My friends are more generally competent (and less harmfully biased) than the modal person writing emissions policy, yes.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: