Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>I am old enough to have witnessed that in 99% of situations people are directly responsible for their own situation

Old people can be wrong, and in this case, they are.

>There is no reason to have empathy.

This is a category mistake. You reason that empathy is superfluous if people are the cause of their misfortune. However, whether people are the cause of their misfortunes is utterly irrelevant to whether there is a reason to have empathy.

So far, none of your arguments have had any discernible logic behind them. If you are so convinced that empathy is needless, why can you not articulate a coherent argument for your position?



You not seeing arguments doesn't invalidate them. You arent the judge on this.


Do you think this response will convince anyone that you are correct? You still fail to provide an argument; you're just being unpleasant. To what end?

Is that what not having empathy in a society feels like? People just talking at each other without any particular goal in mind other than being unpleasant to each other?


> will convince anyone

Are you sure that would be the poster's attempt.

> you're just being

He seems to be discussing, to some of us.


>Are you sure that would be the poster's attempt.

What do you suspect he is attempting to do?


There is a chance he is just seeing whether discussing brings some benefit - as he likes to say. Which is a good thing. Better than the opposite.


There's no discussion happening, though! They're just repeating themselves over and over and ignoring the contents of any replies.


Because the replies ignore the contents of my replies, weird isnt it


Counter perspective: you deflect instead of answering direct questions, which is more like talking at people instead of having dialogue.


This is false. I quoted you and made counterpoints. You repeatedly ignored what I said and instead chose to say peculiar things like, "you arent (sic) the judge on this."

Anyone can read this thread and see this for themselves.


What do I gain from convincing people on the internet about something? Its entertainment for me. Simply showing people how I think is fun. People always act so shocked.


I'm not shocked, but it's not surprising that you don't understand other people's emotions—or your own. You don't just lack empathy; you also lack introspection. I feel strongly that it would be beneficial for you to work on that.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: