Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

>Ending Third Party Fact Checking Program, Moving to Community Notes

CNotes were extremely successful on X.

The problem with censorship, why digg and reddit died as platforms, you end up with second order consequences. The anti-free speech people will always deeply analyze their opponent's speech to find a violation of the rules.

They try to make rules that sound reasonable but are beyond section 230. No being anti-LGBT for ex. But then every joke, miscommunication, etc leads to bans. You also ban entire cultures with this rule. Ive had bans because I meant to add NOT to my 1 sentence, but failed to do so.

Then when it comes to politics. You've banned entire swaths of people/viewpoints. There's no actual meaningful conversation happening on reddit.

Reddit temporarily influenced politics in this way. In a recent election a politician built a platform that mirrored the subreddit. There was polls and if you were to go by reddit... the liberals were about to take at least a minority government, if not majority.

What actually happened? The platform was bizarre and very out of touch with the province. They got blasted in the election. The incumbent majority got stronger.



> CNotes were extremely successful on X.

> reddit died

By all measures I can find, reddit continues to grow year over year, while X seems to have been flat or in decline, so I’m not sure this is a strong premise.


Facebook is #1, followed by youtube.

Tiktok is 4th.

Linkedin is 8th.

X is 12th.

Reddit is 16th.

Reddit fell a great deal in rankings. They mostly use bots to make it appear like they are still relevant. Which ironically is creating a 'dead internet' conspiracy theory. In reality its just 'dead reddit'


Ranked by whom, on what metrics?

What were their relative rankings on the same metrics, say, five years ago?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: