Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

DKIM selectors aren't UUIDs. You can of course use a UUID as a selector, but you don't have to. My selectors are named S-YYYYMM (when I rotate the keys), so my current public key is at S-202001._domainkey.example.com.


A lot of tools generate UUIDs for the selector, just to get something unique without having to ask the user for something relevant or defining some other heuristic. For instance: the built-in helper tool for Zimbra generates a UUID by default, unless you provide something specific. I think a lot of people assume it should be a UUID just because they see UUIDs used in common examples.

Few people think about key cycling for DKIM as it isn't a built-in requirement at all, so once a UUID is set they just keep it until some point in the future that may never happen when they need to revoke the key because the private half is compromised.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: