Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

The juxtaposition is really pretty amazing and, ultimately, frustrating to see.

You can see the far-reaching impact of the odd "Violence yes! Sex no!" American morality in so many places. One recent example that struck me: GTA Online, a game rife with violence and destruction and even sex (surprisingly for an American game), but the chat has a profanity filter that filters words that are otherwise present in the game's scripted dialog and soundtrack left and right.



>>(surprisingly for an American game)

It's made by Rockstar North in Edinburgh. Almost all GTA games have been satires of American culture made by a British company.


Yeah, kinda wish they'd redo GTA 1969 though.


>You can see the far-reaching impact of the odd "Violence yes! Sex no!" American morality in so many places.

1978: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qNLOXJw0aUU

"better get down off that horse, sherrif: we're fixin' ter fuck yeh, now ... but we're not gonna fuck yeh fast; we're gonna fuck yeh sloooooow"


I couldn't believe the Slayer Repentless video is on Youtube (with an age check) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yjb0j9l1sz4. But a tiny bit of nipple is forbidden.


Grand Theft Auto is a British game.


with an American publisher


Oh come on, Europe has been just as permitting of violence as the USA. It's not like Italian giallo and zombie flicks don't exist, or french horror torture porn like Martyrs. Spain had quite the horror film industry with plenty of violence too, like Paul nashy films. Hammer horror in the UK was not shy at all with bloodshed, and even scandinavian horror films were quite the little genre from a bit ago.

European self-righteousness is getting annoying on this forum.


The juxtaposition present in the US is what I'm getting at, not that it's the only country with violent media. The US is A-OK with graphic violence, but try to show a nipple and you've got an uproar on your hands. The imbalance is astounding to me. I'm not European, by the way.


I think the difference might be that war violence is a public event and sexual intimacy is a private one.

Or it could be even simpler and more practical than that, most children don’t have weapons, but they do have human bodies.

Perhaps Apple thinks that the risk of seeming prude is worth it to prevent some kid from falling into sexual abuse and the bigger risk of mom and dad not letting them shop freely for apps.


Chat profanity filtering is usually part of Xbox/PlayStation certification requirements, so their hands might be tied on that.


And those certification requirements are written by whom?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: