Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

It's completely unsurprising that a social movement mirroring the attitude and values of the 1920s anti-saloon league would rediscover temperance as a cause they want to advance. There's always, in all societies, some group that wants to "fix" social ills by banning things and controlling people. These groups, when they get their way, do more harm than good.


Would you see the regulations regarding tabaccomor gambling as efforts that did more harm than good ?

I think there are efforts that are ill placed, and others that counter balance natural harmful tendencies or other efforts from groups benefiting from harmful behavior. I wouldn’t label all banning and efforts to shape a society as useless or counter productive.


Were tobacco and gambling blanket banned like alcohol was on a national level?


Some other examples:

- seat belt laws

- speed limits

- traffic lights

- car and airplane safety standards

- clean air and water regulations


Those are industrial equipment operational safety precautions, not a prohibition of cars and planes




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: