Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Is it easy to disable adblocking on sites that won't work with adblockers? I like to have the option to disable adblocking in my toolbar. For example, certain bank websites, business websites, etc.


People here are gushing amazing over pihole but I don't find it that amazing in the least. In fact what you're describing is one of the most annoying parts of it. I still use it and I did donate to it but it's hardly without it's annoyances. In fact if I didn't already own one I wouldn't build another.

There isn't a chrome extension or anything to white list a site quickly. You have to go back into the interface, login, and whitelist, go back and load the page then you'll find that you needed to whitelist a few subdomains/cdns as well. This is really fun when you've got all your devices using the Pihole for DNS and you can't load something on your phone/TV and need to run to your laptop to deal with it.

If you just got your pihole you probably threw in a bunch of community generated lists and you'll find a good amount of stuff you do visit gets blocked. You can get to Google but not Google drive, so you whitelist it. And you do this over and over again until you finally get annoyed because you just want to make a car payment so you permanently disable it for 5 minutes, or 60 minutes if you've gotten annoyed enough.

Sometimes weeks will go by and you'll forget you even had it disabled at all.

FWIW, I also don't use NoScript because I find it incredibly annoying. This is one step further from the NoScript annoyance because you have to go into the webUI and make your changes.

If you don't mind NoScript you'll probably be fine with Pihole. Or if you have the time to curate and pick lists that fit exactly within your browsing habits.


Yes, there are both manual whitelists and blacklists. There are also easily accessible options for disabling the adblocker permanently or temporarily, in the latter case on a timer of your choosing e.g. for 5 minutes.


Yes, pihole has an easy to use Web interface that allows you to whitelist individual sites. You can also disable adblocking for 5 minutes, or 10 minutes, or until you tell it to start blocking again.


you can add them to your whitelist. It's available through the web interface.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: