Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Perhaps nitpicky, but I took issue with this:

"No other vendor dominates mobile games like Apple now. With over 50,000 games in the App Store, it has 10 and 20 times what Nintendo and Sony offers respectively, and this before Apple’s Game Center has even shipped."

The Nintendo DS is the best selling gaming system of all time, mobile or not. Its not even a competition - they've sold over 2x as many DS's as Apple has sold iPhones.

Not to discredit the iPhone's success in any way, but no one has come close to toppling Nintendo off the gaming throne.



To add to this, consider the number of online flash games there are. By the same logic the author is using, the best mobile gaming platform would be a laptop/netbook.

This of course completely ignores the quality of these games and the advantages that dedicated gaming platforms like the DS and PSP have.


Exactly! Quality not quantity, please. I'm not a big gamer, but it bothers me to read nonsense like the quote above.

Some of the iphone/itouch games (or for that matter, other smartphone-based games) are garbage.


Not sure if the article writer is American -- in many other countries 'mobile' is synonymous with cell phones, and thus 'mobile games' could be interpreted as 'cell phone games'.


The article writer can't mean this because he is comparing Apple to Nintendo. It would make no sense to do so if he meant the market that Apple is dominating to solely mean "cell phone games."


If DS sales is 2x of iPhones, then Apple did beat them, because iPod touches sold more than iPhones (not sure by how much).


No, it sold less. First link I could find says 50 million iPhones and 35 million iPod Touches:

http://www.examiner.com/x-8134-SF-Gadgets-Examiner~y2010m4d8...

(Which may not be correct, but I think the burden of proof is on you if you disagree).


No, I stand corrected.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: